timeform logo mini sign in to timeformSign In

register to timeformRegister
timeform menu collapse

York Preview: I-Dante-ty Parade


Are there any real Derby horses out there? It’s a question that has got louder with every trial, but any answer assumes what a ‘Derby horse’ looks like at this stage. Jamie Lynch looks at the evidence from recent editions of the Derby as he outlines the key points with the one big remaining trial at York this week.

It’s surprising that 43% of people in Britain don’t wash their own cars, the surprising part being that 57% still do. It’s more pronounced in certain areas, according to Paul Yates, Managing Director of AA Cars, who compiled the survey: ‘Whether it’s life getting in the way, or just laziness, many Londoners have no inclination to wash their vehicles.’ And then he went and spoilt it all by saying something stupid like ‘cleaning your car is a prerequisite if you want to sell it.’ He added that Aidan O’Brien is a fair trainer for the Derby.   

I’m not a Londoner, but I am lazy, and the lure of those Eastern European lads at the pop-up car wash in the grounds of the supermarket is too much to resist. Even though I’m a veteran, just four stickers away from the 75 needed for a complimentary wash, I still, every time, have a moment of panic at the key point of key handover at the thought of somebody else driving away in a six-year-old Skoda, as no forms are filled in nor numbers swapped with the easy-going attendant.

But there would never be a case of mistaken identity because our individual identity isn’t easily mistaken. That’s the truth of it, and it’s an uncomfortable truth, especially as the unflattering tags will outweigh the distinguished features. It’s easier to find fault, but that can lead to mistaken identity when it comes to Derby horses out of trials, more acute this year.

Churchill apart, no Derby entrant has put a big number on the board, and none of the mainline trials have produced any wow moments, making for a shapeless market – 5/1 the field – but the Derby is almost unique as a race defined on the day, by the day, and the preliminary past is but a path retrospectively plotted for clues and clarity.

The Derby is the pinnacle in every sense, and the final ascent is the steep, transformative part, something saved for it, by the shrewdest strategist, for their highest climbers, working backwards from Epsom. The Derby makes horses, not the other way around.

The point is that this year’s Epsom field is, by and large, a familiar mix and a classic mix, featuring several ‘Derby horses’ judged on what ‘Derby horses’ traditionally looks like – for form and formation - at this stage, three weeks out, with one big trial still to come. Three-year-olds bringing big ratings with them to Epsom are the exception rather than the rule.

The 2009 Derby had as many as five horses in the line-up with pre-race ratings of 120+: Sea The Stars (128p), Crowded House (122), Gan Amhras (121), Fame And Glory (120p) and Rip Van Winkle (120p). In the seven renewals since then, comprising 90 contenders, as few as eleven brought the same sort of hefty figures with them. Three of them won (Camelot, Australia and Golden Horn), proving the worth of proven worth, but the Derby still can be, and still often is, the domain of the long jumpers, who leap up on the day. Of the other four winners since 2009, Pour Moi was the most experienced with four runs, one more than Harzand, while Workforce and Ruler of The World had raced just twice before Epsom.         

It depends. That’s the short, unhelpful answer to the question of what a Derby horse looks like, but more often than not they’re identifiable by the sum of their hidden parts as much as the sums of their ratings chart. Horses low on mileage and high on breeding who’ve come through trials in whichever way are often the radar runners for Epsom, and you can take your pick of them this year, though two in particular stand out: Cliffs of Moher and Cracksman.

At Chester, Cliffs of Moher passed his test with colours that were speeding towards the end of the runway if not actually flying, and from one’s dress rehearsal to another’s as Cracksman seeks to put on a show in the Dante. Ten unpolished rivals of all shapes and sizes make his trial the best trial in prospect, and if Cracksman can emerge on top then he’ll be in pole position for Epsom. But make no mistake, he, and a few others, are ‘Derby horses’ already, more than you might hear.

It was the Dante, likewise on his third start, likewise for Gosden, that the game really changed for Golden Horn, who scaled such heights at York that only a single rope was needed for the short climb to the Epsom peak. But before the Dante, and even for a while after, the plan was the Derby in France, over the shorter trip.

Here we are again, this time with a filly, en route to Epsom but likelier to divert to France, so goes the talk. In theory, the Musidora is a cakewalk for Shutter Speed, but why it’s important is that there’s every chance she’ll ‘do a Golden Horn’, making Epsom impossible to resist if she’s impressive, hard to think she won’t be against this field with the raw power she looks to have. That Shutter Speed is an Oaks filly isn’t in doubt; the question is which one.




race pass logo

NAVAN 1:20

Sunday 17 December
Davy Russell silk Davy Russell horse in focus
Gordon Elliott, Ireland
D. J. Mullins silk D. J. Mullins
W. P. Mullins, Ireland hot trainer
A. E. Lynch silk A. E. Lynch
Stuart Crawford, Ireland
Go to Full Race



1st B. A. Curtis silk 6. STAR QUALITY 40/141
2nd P. J. McDonald silk nk 4. PEACE TERMS (IRE) 6/42.5f
J: B. A. Curtis  
All 6 ran.


1st B. A. Curtis silk 7. TWIN APPEAL (IRE) 5/23.5f
2nd P. J. McDonald silk ¾ 10. SHEPHERD'S PURSE 12/113
3rd Martin Harley silk ½ 3. EXCHEQUER (IRE) 28/129
J: B. A. Curtis  
T: David Barron  
All 12 ran.


1st B. A. Curtis silk 3. SWIFT EMPEROR (IRE) 11/112
2nd Jack Garritty silk 11. ANDOK (IRE) 13/27.5
3rd P. J. McDonald silk 13. INFLUENT (IRE) 7/18
J: B. A. Curtis  
T: David Barron  
All 13 ran.


1st Fran Berry silk 10. DAILY TRADER 4/15
2nd Luke Morris silk 1 5. RAASHDY (IRE) 2/13f
3rd B. A. Curtis silk nk 3. DOLPHIN VILLAGE (IRE) 11/26.5
J: Fran Berry  
T: David Evans  
10 ran. NRs: 1  9 


1st Jack Duern silk 6. TROPICS (USA) 11/43.75f
2nd Franny Norton silk 7. RAJAR 17/29.5
3rd Fran Berry silk sh 1. SUZI'S CONNOISSEUR 15/28.5
J: Jack Duern (3)  
T: Dean Ivory  
All 9 ran.


1st Edward Greatrex silk 6. PULSATING (IRE) 5/42.25f
2nd Sam James silk 2. JORVIK PRINCE 8/19
3rd Luke Morris silk 1. MOSSY'S LODGE 11/112
11 ran. NRs: 13  9 


1st Luke Morris silk 4. HISAR (IRE) 2/13f
2nd Liam Keniry silk nk 7. FRANK THE BARBER (IRE) 12/113
3rd George Downing silk 13. NONEEDTOTELLME (IRE) 25/126
J: Luke Morris  
12 ran. NRs: 3 


1st Richard Kingscote silk 8. TY ROCK BRANDY (IRE) 7/24.5
2nd Fran Berry silk 1 4. LOS CAMACHOS (IRE) 8/19
3rd Sam James silk 6. IDEAL SPIRIT 40/141
All 8 ran.


1st Ben Robinson silk 4. WINDFORPOWER (IRE) 5/16
2nd Jamie Gormley silk ½ 3. LITTLE MISS LOLA 14/115
3rd Phil Dennis silk ½ 9. FINTRY FLYER 12/113
J: Ben Robinson (5)  
All 11 ran.
Go to Horse Racing Results